The world of women’s basketball is no stranger to viral moments, but Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham may have just delivered one of the funniest—and most unexpected—comments of the year about her superstar teammate Caitlin Clark. What began as a lighthearted social media exchange quickly spiraled into a trending topic that had fans laughing, debating, and sharing clips and memes across the internet.
It all unfolded on Friday night, August 15, 2025, when Cunningham, known for her fiery personality and playful presence both on and off the court, stumbled into a fan-created joke online. A user on X (formerly Twitter) posted two photos side by side: one of Cunningham holding a baby goat, and another of her embracing rookie sensation Caitlin Clark. The fan cheekily suggested that the two photos looked strikingly similar, setting the stage for what would come next.
Rather than ignore the comparison or brush it off, Cunningham leaned all the way into the humor. In her typically candid style, she hit reply with a short but side-splitting comment: “They smell the same too.”
That single sentence was all it took to send fans into a frenzy. Within hours, the post racked up millions of impressions, with users from around the globe weighing in. Some praised Cunningham’s quick wit, others declared her the undisputed “comedian” of the WNBA, and many couldn’t stop laughing at the playful jab. For Caitlin Clark, who has already carried the weight of immense media attention since her arrival in the league, the moment offered a glimpse at the lighter side of life as a professional athlete.
The joke carried extra weight because of what Clark represents to fans of women’s basketball. Since her college days at Iowa, Clark has been celebrated not only for her record-shattering performances but also for the aura of greatness that seems to follow her everywhere. Many have dubbed her the “GOAT” (Greatest of All Time) in the making, even though she’s just getting started at the professional level. That made Cunningham’s baby goat reference all the more clever—turning Clark into both the literal and figurative “GOAT” in one hilarious swoop.
Fans didn’t waste time running with the material. Memes flooded X, Instagram, and TikTok. Some users edited baby goat sound effects into highlight reels of Clark’s step-back threes. Others photoshopped Clark with tiny horns and hooves, jokingly rebranding her as “the kid who runs the WNBA.” Even Fever supporters who usually stick to serious basketball discussions couldn’t help but share in the laughter.
The moment also sparked a broader conversation about the chemistry within the Indiana Fever’s locker room. Cunningham, who joined the team earlier this season, has quickly established herself as a vocal leader and personality. Pairing her vibrant energy with Clark’s competitive drive seems to have created not only an effective on-court partnership but also a dynamic off the court that fans love to watch unfold.
In a league that continues to gain traction and visibility, moments like these serve as reminders that sports are not only about the final score. They’re about personalities, connections, and the shared joy between players and fans. Cunningham’s witty remark, while seemingly small, tapped into the cultural phenomenon surrounding Clark and showcased the kind of authentic interaction that makes the WNBA community feel close-knit and engaging.
What’s more, it highlighted Clark’s ability to handle the endless spotlight with grace. While the joke came at her expense, albeit playfully, Clark embraced it with her usual cool composure. Teammates often say she thrives on pressure but also knows how to laugh at herself—a rare balance that endears her to both peers and supporters.
By the end of the weekend, Cunningham’s “goat smell” comment wasn’t just a passing quip; it had become one of the most talked-about stories in basketball circles. Sports blogs, highlight shows, and even mainstream outlets picked up on the viral moment, proving once again that humor can unite fans just as much as breathtaking performances on the hardwood.
In the ever-growing narrative of Caitlin Clark’s career, this incident will likely be remembered as one of the many colorful anecdotes that define her journey. And for Sophie Cunningham, it was yet another example of how her bold, playful personality brings energy not only to her teammates but also to the wider basketball community.
At the end of the day, Cunningham may have just confirmed what fans already believed: Caitlin Clark isn’t just a great player—she’s the GOAT. And according to Sophie, she might just smell like one too.